Stories in California

MarketLab: The Business of Conservation

It pays to protect nature.

Orchards with rows of trees and mountains in the distance.
MarketLab Northeastern view of the Santa Clara River. TNC has played a large role in protecting the Santa Clara River (SCR) and its tributaries in Southern California. © Melinda Kelley

MarketLab uses business to catalyze conservation in California.

California is the fourth-largest economy in the world, but if we don’t use some of our money to protect our environment, we won’t have a home base to do business from. 

At MarketLab, we’re tapping the potential of California’s enormous capital to protect the thing that matters most: our home.

Putting Business to Work for Conservation

MarketLab sits in TNC’s California chapter. We leverage economics and finance to accelerate conservation.

Blending capital to secure more money for nature: We blend new types of financing with traditional philanthropic and public funding sources. 

  • We develop low-interest loans to acquire farms or ranches for conservation.
  • We steward a revolving fund to protect land at a commercial pace while multiplying the impact of each dollar.

Making the business case to drive policy change: We use economics to drive policy change and greater investment in nature.  

  • We evaluate the public investment needed for forest restoration infrastructure and workforce development to reduce the risk of catastrophic wildfire.
  • We calculate the economic benefits of lithium mining while advocating for policies that will protect nature through the process. 

Creating new markets: We help people and businesses get paid for protecting nature. 

  • We pay farmers to create habitat for migratory birds. 
  • We create groundwater markets that reduce pumping while preserving wildlife-friendly agriculture.
  • We use forest restoration to reduce wildfire risk and make property insurance more affordable.
A landscape view of the Stevenson Property on the Tenaja Corridor.
Tenaja Corridor We were able to successfully acquire the 20-acre Stevenson property through a deal that had to be finalized within just a few months. © Chris Basilevac

What Is the Value of Conservation?

In a changing climate, natural landscapes can mean the difference between life and death for people and nature. But our economy doesn’t value them for what they’re really worth. 

At MarketLab, we unlock nature’s true value. From wildfire resilience insurance to BirdReturns to the Fox Canyon Groundwater Market, the results speak for themselves.

Lesser and greater sandhill cranes mingling in shallow water at Woodbridge Ecological Reserve, Lodi, California.
SIEGE OF SANDHILL CRANES Migratory birds have limited places to land in California’s Central Valley, and the cost of buying enough habitat in the region is high. But why buy when you can rent? © Becky Matsubara

Here’s How MarketLab Works: 

We start with a conservation problem.

Migratory birds have limited places to land in California’s Central Valley, and we can’t afford to buy enough habitat to make a difference. 

A small team with specialized skills in conservation, economics and finance works to develop interventions that will move the needle. 

What if we were to rent the habitat when and where birds need it? 

We implement our market interventions to solve the problem. 

Welcome to BirdReturns. We designed an incentive program that pays Central Valley rice farmers to flood their fields at the exact times migratory birds need to stop and rest.

As of today, our BirdReturns program has provided temporary habitat for more than one million migrating birds at a fraction of the cost of buying land for them. 

A small herd of pronghorn roam across a grassy field at Las Piletas Ranch in eastern San Luis Obispo County.
Las Piletas TNC purchased Las Piletas Ranch in eastern San Luis Obispo County—13,528 acres of rolling foothills, grasslands and oak woodlands, along with 24 miles of streams. © Ethan Inlander/TNC

The Quick Strike Protection Fund

To stay competitive in California’s real estate market, MarketLab developed the Quick Strike Protection Fund, a pool of money TNC uses to acquire conservation properties when deals need to close on short timelines. In a highly competitive real estate market, it’s up to us to help nature strike first.

Why put your money in the ground when it can go to work for nature again and again?

Director of MarketLab

After using it to buy a property, the fund replenishes itself when TNC resells the land to a public agency committed to conservation. This way, we can recover the full cost of the acquisition and put the money back into the fund to acquire more land for nature. 

YOUR DONATION

When donors commit to the Quick Strike Protection Fund, their dollars are used time and time again, multiplying the impact of each gift while also making TNC far more effective in a competitive market. A $10 million fund could have a $50 million impact over the course of several years, as it is deployed, recovered and redeployed.

For a limited time, each gift of $10,000 or more will be matched by a TNC donor, who has generously pledged up to $500,000 in match funds. 

If you are interested in donating to the Quick Strike Protection Fund, contact Kelly Brown, associate director of development, at kelly.brown@tnc.org.

A farm stand in Ventura County, with brightly painted signs advertising their products, such as flowers.
VENTURA FARM STAND TNC has played a large role in protecting the Santa Clara River and its tributaries in Southern California by preserving agriculture that buffers nature from urban development, using market-based tools. © Melinda Kelley

Market-based Conservation Projects 

A flock of migratory birds flies over a cornfield.
BirdReturns Migratory birds flock above corn fields on Staten Island. © Erika Nortemann/The Nature Conservancy

Scaling BirdReturns While Saving Water

We’re working to scale BirdReturns to provide 100,000 acres of seasonal migratory bird habitat each year. This past fall, we expanded the program to California’s Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta, pairing payments for creating bird habitat with incentives to save water by reducing irrigation or growing cover crops instead of cash crops. 

MarketLab applied our learnings from BirdReturns to help the Delta Conservancy improve a new incentive program, saving more water and more money. In its second year, the Delta Conservancy program became the first California agency to use a “reverse auction,” the same structure BirdReturns uses. This new approach reduced costs by one-third, freeing up more funding for water conservation and bird habitat in the Delta. 

Expand to see more Collapse to see less
Farming for Bird Habitat in California's Delta (4:21) Located in the heart of the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta, Staten Island has 8,500 acres of farmland where TNC is researching wildlife-friendly agriculture and irrigation techniques that promote bird conservation in this essential habitat.
Aerial view of a lithium mine.
Clayton Valley The Chemetall Foote Lithium Operation in Clayton Valley, a dry lake bed in Esmeralda County, Nevada, just east of Silver Peak, a tiny town that has been host to various kinds © Doc Searls, used under a Creative Commons Attribution

Mining Lithium Sustainably

MarketLab led the economic analysis for a new report, Potential Lithium Extraction in the United States: Environmental, Economic, and Policy Implications. The study catalogues the potential extraction sites for lithium—a key metal used in rechargeable batteries for electric vehicles and in power grid storage—across the continental United States. It also maps potential impacts on nature and wildlife and highlights the need for more policy guidance on where and how lithium projects should be prioritized or discouraged in order to ensure good outcomes for people, the climate and nature. 

Our work was featured in articles in Politico and the Desert Sun, an important local media outlet near the Salton Sea, the site of California’s largest proposed lithium mine. 

Expand to see more Collapse to see less
A house with a fire raging in the background.
"Glass Fire" In the face of climate change and extended drought, our groundwater market tool makes it easier to manage water for nature and people. © © Jerry Dodrill

Wildfire Resilience Insurance

Science shows that ecological forest restoration reduces the risk of severe wildfires. But should insurance pricing be lower where restoration has taken place?

The answer is yes.  Read our full report and summary report.

Based on this work, we’ve partnered with the insurance industry to create a new product that pays for forest restoration. Prescribed burning and the removal of smaller trees and other vegetation in overgrown forests can cut insurance premiums by over 40%. These savings could be used to fund further investments in sustainable forest management.

Expand to see more Collapse to see less
A farmworker on an avocado farm in Somis, CA.
Ventura County Farm In the face of climate change and extended drought, our groundwater market tool makes it easier to manage water for nature and people. © USDA

Catalyzing Groundwater Markets for Nature

Despite recent flooding, California’s drought is here to stay. New water restrictions have been hard on agriculture, and water markets can provide farmers with flexibility. In a cap-and-trade system, farmers who temporarily fallow their lands can sell their water to farmers who need more water than allocated, allowing them to avoid hefty fines. 

In 2020, TNC launched the first groundwater market under California’s Sustainable Groundwater Management Act. The Fox Canyon groundwater market in Ventura County benefits both people and nature by preserving one of the country’s most productive agricultural regions on the outskirts of the Los Angeles metro area, where development pressure is strong. These agricultural lands provide an important buffer for habitat and create opportunities for groundwater recharge and storage that are not possible on developed lands. 

The first market under California’s new groundwater law, Fox Canyon is a model that can be replicated in more than 250 groundwater basins across the state. This new market is now shaping state policy, playing a key role in the California Water Commission’s recent recommendations on how best to enable groundwater trading while safeguarding vulnerable resources.

Expand to see more Collapse to see less
Aerial view of the Elkhorn Slough (Monterey Bay)
ESTUARY RESTORATION Aerial view of the Elkhorn Slough, an estuary on Monterey Bay and Moss Landing Harbor, in California. Elkhorn Slough is the second-largest remaining salt marsh in California and hosts a tremendous diversity of plant and animal life. This rich habitat has been held together by decades of collaborative conservation. © Kiliii Yuyan

Valuing Salt Marshes as Flood Mitigation

MarketLab has partnered with UC Santa Cruz’s Coastal Resilience Lab to assess the flood reduction benefits of salt marshes in San Mateo County, the California county with the greatest exposure to sea-level rise. This first-of-its-kind analysis found that with one meter of sea-level rise, existing and restored salt marshes could provide nearly $500 million in avoided flood damages countywide. 

The opportunities for leveraging this value are numerous, from shaping the design of marsh restoration projects in San Mateo County to engaging with the Federal Emergency Management Agency and the insurance industry on incorporating salt marshes into their respective models.

This work builds on TNC’s role in the creation of a new insurance policy for the Mesoamerican Reef, which protects Mexico’s Yucatan tourism industry from the impacts of hurricanes. Our goal is to use natural infrastructure to protect communities as our state faces more and more severe disasters. 

Expand to see more Collapse to see less

If you’d like to get involved in MarketLab, contact Sarah Heard, director of MarketLab, at sarah.heard@tnc.org.